Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

  • 11.14.22

Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

As thoughts turn to Thanksgiving, football fans prepare a slew of games that will hopefully be classics instead of stinkers. To that end, coaches are busy working on their game plan to avoid any unexpected — and unpleasant — surprises.

Well, if this Thanksgiving you’re tasked with preparing a feast — or maybe just a special meal for your family — then you also need a game plan as well to ensure that you have a happy and stress-free experience.

Of course, this is easier said than done! Cooking for Thanksgiving is a high-pressure event, like preparing to play in the Superbowl. If things go wrong, then it’s not like there’s another Thanksgiving right around the corner. It’s a full year away.

Fortunately, you don’t have to brace for impact and pray that the cooking gods look favorably upon you this year. Instead, you can follow this practical and proven game plan and head for the end zone —where you can do a triumphant victory dance!

Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

One Month Before Thanksgiving

In the Art of War, Sun Tzu sagely advises that a battle is won or lost before it is fought. I expect the immortal Vince Lombardi preached something similar in his many pre-game locker room speeches.

What this means to you is simple: don’t set yourself up for stress and struggles by waiting until the last minute to prepare your menu. Put an initial menu together and post it for everyone in your family to see (a fridge is a good place).

It would be best if you also invited — I would say insist — that your family provide you with feedback now, not later. It’s like what they say at weddings: speak now or forever hold your peace!

And of course, you can undoubtedly change your initial recipe in any manner you wish, from minor tweaks to wholesale re-inventions.

I have often experienced that simply writing out a menu and posting it triggers creative ideas. And even if I end up with a menu that looks nothing like the original version, I know that the first draft played a pivotal role in the final version.

Oh, and one more helpful life hack: if you’re working with cookbooks or checking out recipes online, make sure to write down/bookmark the page.

You’ll have a lot on your mind in the weeks ahead, and you don’t want to spend hours trying to hunt down a recipe.

Or better yet, copy the recipe or print it out and put it in a file.

Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

Two Weeks Before Thanksgiving

With two weeks to go, you should have a final menu ready that everyone in your family (and on your guest list if you choose a broad distribution) is excited about.

Even if you’re still taking care of some minor details, you should know what the main dish will be — because this is when you want to place your order for your turkey, goose, prime rib, and so on.

Also, you want to inspect all the linens you will use. I’m deliberately using the word “inspect” instead of “check” — because you don’t want to discover unsightly stains and creases on Thanksgiving day.

So do an inspection, dry clean and press if necessary.

It’s also a good idea to purchase all of the non-perishable grocery items you’ll need, including wine, champagne, and drinks. If you’re using a bread base stuffing or any vegetable dish, you can also be proactive and prepare the onions, carrots, celery, and garlic. Store them in separate containers and freeze them until needed.

One Week Before Thanksgiving

The excitement is mounting!  With one week to go, it’s time to prepare the cranberry sauce and purchase all of the items that will be hard to find as the clock ticks down, like chestnuts.

Three Days Before Thanksgiving

Three days to go! In Superbowl terms, the officials are checking out the field to make sure everything is perfect, the TV personalities are getting their make-up done, the half-time talent is testing out the sound system, and fans are streaming in from across the country and around the world.

You also have fans — your family and any other guests — and they’re counting on you to razzle and dazzle. No problem! You got this. Here’s the checklist with 72 hours to go:

  • Start baking cookies and any other sweet treats that can be stored (as a bonus, your house will smell amazing!).
  • Start preparing appetizers that can be rewarmed at the last minute.
  • Carefully get out the holiday china, crystals, and silverware you will use. Polish as necessary, and get vases and table decorations ready.

Two Days Before Thanksgiving

With two days to go, you’ll thank yourself for the preparation work you started doing almost a month ago. While other people were scrambling and stressed out, you’ll be cool, calm, and collected. Here’s the checklist:

  • Do all remaining grocery shopping.
  • Purchase flowers (if desired).
  • Bake pies and cakes.
  • Set the table (aren’t you glad you inspected the linen vs. just checked it?)
  • Roast vegetables and make the stock base for gravy (which you can store).
Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

One Day Before Thanksgiving

The day before Thanksgiving is fast-paced. Make sure you stretch, drink plenty of water, and are in-game shape — because you’ll need to be at your best! Here’s what’s on the checklist with just 24 hours to go:

  • Clean and prepare all the vegetables and store them.
  • Cook sweet potato dishes.
  • Prepare the turkey stuffing and start the gravy base.
  • Prepare flower centerpieces (hint: choose something small and low so you can have an easy conversation), and store them in the refrigerator or a cool place.
  • Assign serving dishes with silverware, and set the table where all the dishes will be placed if you do a buffet-style
  • Set up all champagne glassware and small appetizer plates on an easily accessible table or on a counter away from the kitchen workspace (and no sampling — there will be plenty of time for that later!)

Thanksgiving Day

So it begins. The big moment is just hours away. However, before you can bask in the glory of your majestic creation — and in the smiles and “wow, this is all so amazing!”— you still have some vital work to do. Here are your tasks for the final stretch:

  • Stuff the turkey and cook.
  • Get all the sweets, appetizers, and sweet potatoes out so they can reach room temperature.
  • Peel, cut, and cook the mashed potatoes.
  • Prepare all vegetables based on your menu (my favorites include carrots, Brussels sprouts, and green beans).
  • Warm up what needs to be reheated.
  • Set drink and appetizer table.

The Kickoff

You did it! You’ve done so much work and should be immensely proud of yourself. Enjoy the day, and remember that YOU are the one who made it happen!



Enjoy some of our favorite Holiday Season recipes:

Roasted Sweet Potatoes, Brussels Sprouts and Cranberries

Thanksgiving Side Dishes

Chestnut Stuffed Turkey


Cooking a Thanksgiving Feast this Year? Here’s Your Game Plan!

Originally published on October 26, 2018. Updated November 14, 2022.

Shop My Favorites

Shop and save from the comfort of your home

Shop a collection of my favorite kitchen tools, books and more.

Shop Now

Comments (1) Post a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *